Best ‘My Pillow’ Alternatives

If you are looking for one of the best pillows in the world, then the “My Pillow” brand is a name to remember.

Unfortunately, being such a high-class and sought-after brand, “My Pillow” is expensive.
So for those who want the experience of a “My Pillow” without a price tag, here are a few excellent My Pillow competitors!

About the “My Pillow” Brand

Reviewing the quality and size of the pillow
Let us first look at exactly what makes “My Pillow” products so special;

“My Pillow” is an extensively advertised trademark for bed pillows manufactured in Chanhassen, Minnesota. This pillow became famous due to plenty of television infomercials and its remarkable success in sales and performance.

What is in “My Pillow” Products?

  • The “My Pillow” is filled with high-quality polyurethane foam shredded into different-sized shapes and pieces. These irregulars and small-shaped pieces allow the pillow to be easily reshaped to comfort your body’s contours.
  • Similarly, these irregularly shaped fillings help the pillow to maintain its shape, which results in enhanced comfort and support, which far surpasses most other pillow brands in the market.

Benefits of the “My Pillow”

So How will the “My Pillow” or a similar alternative benefit you?

On the other hand, if “My Pillow” is not your cup of tea, but you are looking for something similar, then read to find pillows similar to My Pillow.

What to Look for in an Alternative for ‘My Pillow’?

My Pillow Alternatives 1

The main thing to look for in pillows like My Pillow is irregular-shaped shredded fillings, whether foam, polyurethane, or buckwheat. The main purpose of the “My Pillow” pillows is to reshape and conform to your body’s contours without permanently losing its original shape.

Also, check for the covers. Look for something in a cotton or natural fiber that is removable and hypoallergenic.

How We Test and Score ‘My Pillow’ Alternatives

 Checking how the pillow can be easily reshaped on its own which can offer support and comfortability
These reviews are based on intense research, analysis, and feedback from our experts and real users from different digital platforms.

We spent 19 hours trying, testing, and scoring these ‘My Pillow’ Alternatives for different key parameters and then shortlisted the best products in the market, saving you time and effort.

We used the following parameters for our tests and analysis.

  • Quality – We researched how long users can use the pillows without any reported changes in the quality or design.
  • Versatility – We tested the pillows’ versatility in different places.
  • Hypoallergenic – We observed how the pillows likely trigger an allergic reaction.
  • Comfort – We checked how comfortable and safe the pillows were.
  • Price -We checked the pillow’s affordability having good quality.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About ‘My Pillow’ Alternatives

  1. What is inside MyPillow?
    The pillows’ filling is made from 100% polyurethane foam, which allows them to be shaped, fluffed, and folded easily. The polyfoam is shredded to improve the pillow’s breathability and make it simpler to manage beneath the cover fabric.

  2. Why is the cold side of the pillow better?
    It turns out that having a cool head aids the body’s core temperature regulation. When we become too hot, we try to cool off by pumping blood to our hands, feet, and head. Our bodies cool down and help us to sleep more deeply by transferring heat to the pillow.

  3. How many pillows should you sleep with?
    According to a sleep expert, you should sleep with only one pillow under your head; yet, when determining the comfort of your sleeping posture, personal choices of the number of pillows are typically considered.

  4. How often wash MyPillow?
    Even if the item is clean, we recommend laundry every four months. If you have allergies, you should wash them every two months or less as needed and use the right detergent.

Reviews: The Best “My Pillow” Alternative Available Today

Here are some great options for alternatives to the “My Pillow.”
We hope you love the ‘My Pillow’ alternatives we recommend!
So that you know, We may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page.

Reviewed by: Eliza Ward Score: 98.9

If you want the perfect blend of support and plush comfort, the Adjustable loft pillow from Coop Home Goods is one of the best My Pillow alternatives.
  • Inside is an adjustable blend of different shapes and sizes of memory foam pieces.
  • The ultra-soft Bamboo derived Rayon casing is of superior quality.
  • This pillow is ideal for sleeping in any position possible.
  • The luxury outer cover is made from sustainable bamboo, offering excellent breathability and comfortable sleeping.

  • Adjustability.
  • Made in USA.
  • Allergy Reduction.
  • Needs to be cleaned regularly.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%97

Here’s a great alternative to get the same comfort as the pillows from the My Pillow brand.
  • This Casper pillow has been crafted with duck down and feather filling with a premium quality design. Even after months of regular use, you will not have any feathers poking through.
  • The filling has also been ethically sourced and ensures complete breathability and comfort for the sleeper.
  • It features a 100% cotton outer fabric and a 100% polyester inner fabric.
  • When it’s time for cleaning, toss it into your washing machine and wash it regularly.

  • Optimal Air Circulation.
  • Promotes Healthy Alignment.
  • Versatility.
  • Too Soft for Some Users.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%96

These Pancake Pillows offer a unique style of pillow wherein you can add or remove the layers of thinner pillows from the main shaft for the most comfortable pillow height.
  • You’ll get six plush stackable inner pillows, each filled with the softest down alternative microfiber filling.
  • Thanks to the height adjustability, it is suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers.
  • The outer zippered case is made from 100% cotton fabric with a 300 fabric count.
  • Apart from being soft, the pillows are also hypoallergenic.

  • Quality.
  • Prevent Condition.
  • Elevate Sleep Comfort.
  • Too Soft for Some Users.

Rating CategoryWeight %Score
Total Score100%94.75

The EnerPlex Never Flat Pillow is filled with shape-holding shredded memory foam that is completely adjustable. This pillow is great if you are looking for My Pillow alternatives with a better price offer.

  • It comes in options for head, body, and knee pillow sizes.
  • This pillow is filled with Certi-PUR-certified memory foam shredded for adjustability.
  • It is covered with a breathable and cooling bamboo cover.
  • Premium-quality design.

The Meoflaw Gel Pillow is a unique 3D-embossed gel pillow designed to give you a great option for a My Pillow alternative.
  • Its high-quality fiber creates a no-shift construction providing efficient support while ensuring softness.
  • This Amazon’s Choice product comes in a vacuum-sealed bag and is relatively easy to maintain.
  • It it is machine-washable.
  • Besides, these pillows are recommended for people who sleep on their sides or back.

Confirming how perfectly soft and comfortable are the Meoflaw's alternative gel pillow

A Premium Centi-PUR certified Memory filled pillow with a cooling bamboo cover from Clara Clark, similar to the My Pillow Brand.
  • It comes in a two-pack king-size option.
  • Memory foam-filled pillow with a cooling bamboo cover.
  • Soft and breathable.
  • Reduces neck and back pain.

Examining how soft and breathable are the Clara Clark's alternative pillow

An excellent choice of adjustable loft pillows is the WonderSleep premium, which is truly an enjoyable experience to sleep on. In this plush memory foam, you can look forward to uncompromised comfort, support, and a breathable and hypoallergenic pillow.
  • It is a shredded memory foam filling that can be removed or added to adjust the pillow’s firmness for a comfortable night’s rest.
  • The premium fabric covering ensures that your pillow stays relaxed and comfortable during the night.
  • The shredded memory foam offers personalized support for your head, neck, and shoulders, relieving pain and tension.
  • This pillow is similarly mite-resistant while being hypoallergenic.

 Analyzing the memory foam filling of the WonderSleep alternative pillow

With its memory foam filling and luxury bamboo cover, you can snuggle up with the Snuggle-Pedic Ultra-Luxury pillow.
The ideal, hypoallergenic, and adjustable loft combination for safe and sound sleeping makes it perfect for My Pillow alternatives.
  • Filled with shredded memory foam for superior support and comfort.
  • Adjustable loft to give you the best customizable sleeping position.
  • The cover is hypoallergenic, superbly breathable, and cooling.
  • Manufactured from the highest quality Polyester, Lycra, Viscose, and Bamboo fibers.

SHEEX Original Performance Pillows are crafted with patented open-cell technology, making them a great My Pillow alternative.
  • This product’s design allows air and moisture to pass through the pillow, helping you stay cool all night.
  • Besides, their use of soft athletic fabrics lulls you into a comfortable sleep.
  • Also, these pillows are effortless to wash. And you can put these in the washing machine in a cold wash setting.
  • These pillows are designed not to shrink, pill, or fade and can be tumble dried on a low setting.

The Pure Comfort Rachel features it all, shredded memory foam, bamboo cover, and all CertiPur certified.
  • It is filled with Certo-PUR-certified quality memory foam.
  • The cover is a cooling Tencel material cover that is also removable.
  • No toxic substances or odor as with other memory foam pillows.
  • Also, Hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant, the cover is similarly removable and washable.
  • The pillow has a curved and gusseted design for optimal support and body alignment.

A true My Pillow alternative with luxury design and premium materials for comfort and support.
  • Available in a standard, queen, or King-sized option.
  • It is filled with memory foam that is adjustable and soft.
  • A premium cooling Bamboo cover.
  • Hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant.
  • Ideal for all sleeping positions.

The Official Memory Foam Pillow from Enther is another quality brand that you can easily refer to among My Pillow alternatives.
One of the most comfortable pillows you will ever own, offering exceptional support for your back and neck.
  • It is manufactured from the finest quality Organic Cotton and Polyester.
  • The Viscose and Polyester cover is removable and washable, has a soft feel, and enhanced breathability.
  • CertiPUR-US certified foam is manufactured without ozone depleters, flame retardants, mercury, and other toxic materials inside.
  • This pillow is designed to be durable yet highly comfortable and reliable.
  • The pillow is designed to be cooling and adjustable with a removable fill.

Index Table: ‘My Pillow’ Alternatives

1Coop Home Goods Adjustable Loft - My Pillow Alternative
  • Shredded Memory Foam Inner
  • Bamboo Cover
Coop Home Goods98.9
2Casper Sleep Duck Down - My Pillow Alternative
  • 100% Cotton Fabric
  • Machine Washable
Casper Sleep97.6
3Pancake Pillow Adjustable Layer Pillow - Luxury My Pillow Alternative
  • 100% Cotton Cover
  • Down Alternative Fiber
  • Imported
Pancake Pillow96.3
4EnerPlex Never Flat - Luxury My Pillow Alternative
  • Bamboo Cover
  • Memory Foam Fill
5MeoFlaw Luxury - Alternative Gel Pillow
  • Microfiber
  • Fluffy
6Clara Clark Premium - My Pillow Alternative
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Washable
  • Cooling Bamboo Cover
Clara Clark96.6
7WonderSleep Premium - Adjustable Loft
  • Memory Foam
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Breathable Cover
8Snuggle-Pedic Ultra-Luxury - Bamboo My Pillow Alternative
  • Bamboo Cover
  • Memory Foam
  • Breathable
  • Hypoalergenic
9Sheex Hypoallergenic - Down Alternative Pillow
  • Polyester
  • Plush
10Pure Comfort Advanced - Premium My Pillow Alternative
  • Memory Foam
  • Hypoalergenic
  • Washable Cover
  • Curved design
Pure Comfort96.9
11Sleepsia Premium - My Pillow Alternative
  • Bamboo Cover
  • memry Foam Fill
  • Adjustable
12Enther Shredded Memory Foam - Bed Pillow Adjustable Loft
  • Memory Foam
  • Non-Toxic
  • Removable Cover

About the Author

Eliza Ward

Eliza Ward is a health and body posture enthusiast, nature lover, and full-time mother for 3 lovely kids in South Africa. She has always had a fetish for pillows and has the best product recommendations for all her friends and family. So she turned what she loved into her full-time job - by testing and recommending the best pillows for our online readers. Read her reviews to know how detailed her observations are.